Samsung’s “Smart Photo Editing” offers a powerful experience for removing unwanted elements, while Apple’s Clean Up tool struggles to match accuracy and realism, according to a new evaluation.
Article contents:
- Comparison background
- Practical results
- Key highlights of Samsung’s superiority
- Weakness of Apple’s Clean Up tool
- Differences in design vision
- Impact on users
- The future of smart photo editing
- Comparison summary
- Frequently asked questions
1. Comparison background
Apple is considered a pioneer in the smartphone world and introduced the “Clean Up” tool as part of the AI features on iOS. In contrast, Samsung raised the bar by adding advanced features to its Galaxy S25 smartphone series, especially in photo editing and removing unwanted elements.
A reviewer who has been using the iPhone since 2009 tested both tools, and the result was astonishing in Samsung’s favor, as the AI accuracy in “Smart Photo Editing” left them deeply impressed.
Galaxy S25 Ultra: when artificial intelligence meets hardware power
2. Practical results
The comparison included four different examples of removing objects, elements, or even people from various scenes, ranging from pet photos to a crowded cafe scene. In every test, Samsung was able to reconstruct backgrounds realistically and consistently with lighting and shadows, while Apple’s attempt seemed modest, often leaving distorted shadows or blurred patches in place of the removed elements.
3. Key highlights of Samsung’s superiority
“Smart Photo Editing” successfully tracked background extensions and wove missing details together in a way that makes the user imagine the original photo is completely free of the removed element. This included redrawing surface textures and colors to match the scene. It also managed to preserve natural shadows impressively; when an object is removed, surrounding shadows are adjusted or removed harmoniously.
4. Weakness of Apple’s Clean Up tool
“Clean Up” appears less advanced in predicting what lies behind the removed element. When deleting a pet or a person, illogical shadows remain or the area fills with strange pixels. This limitation may be due to Apple’s reliance on less comprehensive algorithms, or a lack of training models that focus on image composition compared to Samsung’s more comprehensive approach.
5. Differences in design vision
Some analysts point out that Apple follows a conservative approach, preferring to improve natural photography rather than adding large-scale editing technologies. On the other hand, Samsung is betting on visual creativity and showcasing the capabilities of AI in phones, which aligns with its marketing strategy supporting innovation.
6. Impact on users
Amateur and professional users alike benefit from AI photo editing tools, whether preparing social media posts or producing more professional work. These features save time and effort in photo editing without the need for complex external applications. With Samsung leading this round, this may change some users’ choices when purchasing their next phone.
Gemini versus Google Assistant: what is the difference and which is smarter?
7. The future of smart photo editing
As companies increasingly rely on AI in cameras and photo editing, the market is expected to see even fiercer competition on this front. Apple’s tool may improve in upcoming updates, while Samsung and other companies will continue to refine their models and offer broader capabilities, such as adding new elements or replacing entire backgrounds without leaving traces of manipulation.
8. Comparison summary
The latest evaluation indicates a clear superiority for Samsung in the field of “Smart Photo Editing,” especially in removing elements and reconstructing backgrounds with realistic accuracy. Although Apple remains a leader in other areas such as environmental services and ease of use, this comparison highlights the need to develop the “Clean Up” tool to keep pace with the competition in the coming years.
Frequently asked questions
1. Is the photo editing difference between Apple and Samsung really significant?
According to practical tests, yes; Samsung showed much better results in removing elements.
2. Will Apple update the Clean Up tool in the future?
This is expected, especially with growing interest in AI capabilities.
3. Does “Smart Photo Editing” support removing large objects?
Tests indicate the ability to remove elements of various sizes with impressive results.
4. Can these features be used in different languages?
Photo editing is not tied to language as it relies on visual analysis of images, so it is usable globally.
5. Does the user need technical expertise to perform these edits?
Usually no, as the tool interfaces are easy and simple, relying on quick touches.
6. Which phones support this feature on Samsung?
It is available on the Galaxy S25 series and some updated models.
7. Is AI limited to removing elements only?
No, there are broader features including lighting enhancement, color adjustment, and adding creative effects.
